Home
Downloads     
Articles Previews Blogs Popular Hardware Price & Performance Forum Get Toolbar
YouGamers.com Reviews Ship Simulator 2008

Ship Simulator 2008


User Rating: Log in to rate this game!
ESRB rating: Everyone ESRB:
Publisher: Lighthouse Interactive Game Publishing
Genre(s): Simulation
Home Page: http://www.shipsim.com/
 






Preview





 
 
By: Aaron Barnes Sep 14, 2007

Fire in the engine room!

Audio is very basic, with no support for advanced acceleration. Stock samples give sound to the waves and engine, but harbors are noticeably silent. A working harbor is generally a cacophony of horn blasts, engines and various dock noises, from cranes to workers. The silence, as they say, is deafening. The same goes for the complete omission of radio functionality. Maritime radio is a crucial aspect of a journey at sea, as verbal communication is critical in busy ports. Without radio chatter, almost all immersion is lost. Even the passengers you ferry or rescue refuse to speak. As my grandmother always said, one "Thank You" can go a long way.

Frequently, a boat will become stuck in a gravity-defying position.

These shortcomings – lackluster audio, over-simplified controls – could be forgiven if it weren't for the issues with the ships' handling. Or, rather, the lack of believability in handling. Piloting a ship is a nuanced affair, and a vessel's movement on water is a combination of water forces (waves, currents and tides), wind forces (which affect the vessel directly at the hull and indirectly through the water) and engine forces (via the propeller or propellers, which work with or against the wind and water forces). In Ship Simulator, water is simply a plane that the hull cuts through – with some resistance, of course. There is no accurate physics modeling taking place, either above or below the water line.

Wind has no direct effect on a ship (which it certainly should), but it does correspond to taller waves. Despite this, a patrol boat will roll over the highest of crests in the roughest of seas without deviating from its course. Even the most powerful engines can't overcome the rolling and pitching seas that gale-force winds generate. But the boats in Ship Simulator 2008 are straight from the Ron Popiel mindset (he of the "Set It and Forget It" line of cooking products); just set the ship's course and pay no attention to the 25-knot winds and 5-meter crests.

Ready for an adventure at sea!
... or not. Every so often my craft would sink immediately after the mission started.

The problems don't end there. Despite having a full day-to-night cycle, there are no tides. Even when a ship has forward movement but the engines are in neutral, the rudders don't work (as long as there is water passing over them, they should). Ships will rarely capsize (except when they inexplicably sink due to a bug), even when performing outlandish turns at high speed or taking extreme damage below the water line. Collision detection is a rough approximation, likely done with a bounding box, making way for unrealistic ship-to-ship contact. It was possible for a ship which draws many feet to continue into shallower water without running aground. The list goes on and on, but you get the point – the ship physics is appropriate for Grand Theft Auto, not an authentic ship simulation.

It's difficult to complete objectives at the bottom of the harbor.




 

Related Stuff

 Reviews: Silent Hunter 4 - Wolves of the Pacific   Apr 20, 2007
 Reviews: Test Drive Unlimited   Mar 12, 2007
 Reviews: Flight Simulator X   Mar 06, 2007

Tags




  About Us     Privacy and Legal     Game-o-Meter FAQ     Contact Us     Advertise With Us     Jobs     Futuremark